Why non-married co-owners of a home in Maryland should enter into a written agreement on how they will share the cost of home ownership and divide the equity upon sale.

by | Aug 12, 2024 | Firm News | 0 comments

In 2023, eighteen percent (18%) of first-time home buyers were non-married couples.    Due to the high price of real estate, the incomes from both parties are usually needed to qualify for a mortgage.  The non-married parties are both responsible for paying for the mortgage.  The non-married couple usually title their home as tenants in common.

The ownership of a real estate by non-married couples presents an obvious challenge, namely what should happen to the home if their relationship ends.

When non-married persons purchase a home together in Maryland, they should enter into a written agreement regarding how they will share the cost of home ownership and divide the equity upon sale.   The agreement should address four topics.  First, the agreement should specify each party’s contribution towards the down payment of the home.  Secondly, the agreement should specify how the parties will share in the cost of the mortgage (principle, interest, taxes, and insurance) as well as other household expenses (utilities, HOA fees, groceries, home maintenance, etc.).   Thirdly, the agreement should address what happens if a party breaches his or her promise towards contributing to the mortgage and/or household expenses.  Finally and most importantly, the agreement needs to specify how the equity in the home will be divided upon the sale of the home.

        A.  ENFORCEABILITY OF EQUITY SHARING AGREEMENTS

When co-tenants have entered into an agreement regarding the division of net equity upon the sale of their home, the court is required to enforce their agreement.   The authority is found in Real Property Code § 1-104, which provides that “any person may vary by agreement the effect of any provision of this article”.   Note that sales in lieu of partition are governed by Real Property Code § 14-701 et seq.  

A co-tenants’ right to enforce an agreement regarding the sale of a jointly owned home or division of proceeds in a sale in lieu of partition case was upheld in Balderston v. Balderston, 40 Md.App 239, 243 (1978).  The court stated “the agreement made between the parties respecting partition and sale is valid and enforceable”. 

        B.  WHEN THERE IS NO AGREEMENT BETWEEN NON- MARRIED CO-                        OWNERS OF REAL ESTATE

When non-married co-owners of real estate do not have a written agreement concerning how they will share the cost of home ownership and how the equity will be divided upon the sale of the home, either co-owner has the right to file a complaint for sale in lieu of partition in Circuit Court in Maryland.  The court will appoint a trustee to sell the home and determine how the net equity should be divided between the parties.  The disadvantages of sale in lieu of partition lawsuit is that litigation is time consuming, frustrating, and can be very expensive.

Success in a sale in lieu of partition case will depend upon the party’s ability to present evidence (such as canceled checks and credit card statements) showing that he or she paid more half of the mortgage obligation.  Marshalling evidence of each party’s contribution towards home ownership expenses could be problematic if the parties have co-owned the home for many years, because financial institutions usually maintain records for only seven (7) years.

              1.   A NON-MARRIED COTENANT’S RIGHT TO                                                                      PROPORTIONATE CONTRIBUTION IS MANDATORY

A cotenant, who pays for more than half of the mortgage obligation, is entitled to contribution from the other co-tenant.  Kamin-A-Kalaw v. Dulic, 322 Md. 49, 51 (1991) (“Where property is jointly owned, it is well-settled that a cotenant who makes payments to preserve the property is entitled to contribution from his cotenants for their share of the payment); Pino v. Clay, 251 Md. 456-457 (1968) (“The general rule in Maryland is that when one tenant pays a mortgage or other encumbrance upon the common property, he is entitled to contribution from his co-tenants to the extent to which he had paid their share, and is entitled to an equitable lien for the amount due him”).

A cotenant’s right to contribution extends to the payment of liens and encumbrances, including “mortgages, taxes, and ground rent”.  Lingo v. Lingo, 257 Md. 707, 711 (1973) (quoting Hogan v. McMahon, 115 Md. 195, 201 (1911)).   “The right to contribution between cotenants exists to insure that a cotenant of property who advances money for the common benefit of all of the contents should be reimbursed by his contenants for their pro rata share of the money advanced”.  Kamin-A-Kalaw at 54.

The issue of the absolute right to contribution between non-married cotenants was addressed in Kamin-A-Kalaw v. Dulic, 322 Md. 49, 51 (1991).  The Maryland Supreme Court held that “[w]here property is jointly owned, it is well-settled that a cotenant who makes payment to preserve the property is entitled to contribution from his cotenants for their share of the payments” (emphasis added). 

The Maryland Supreme Court ruled that the paying cotenant was entitled to contribution in the amount of 50%, thereby overruling the 25% contribution that the Appellate Court of Maryland had awarded.   Id. at 55 (“We disagree with the decision of the intermediate appellate court.  Under its holding, Dulic would only be required to contribute one-fourth of the amount advanced by Kamin-A-Kalaw for the mortgage payments, insurance, and taxes on the property”); Spessard v. Spessard, 64 Md.app. 83, 93 (1985) (quoting 2 American Law of Property § 6.17) (holding that when one non-married “cotenant ‘pays more than his share of taxes, interest, on mortgages, and other necessary carrying charges’, equity imposes on each cotenant the duty to contribute his proportionate share, since his interest has been protected by extinction by a tax or foreclosure sale”).

The Spessard court further acknowledged the right to proportionate contribution between non-married cotenants is mandatory: “The rules pertaining to contribution have withstood time and are not be overruled lightly.  Nor do we undertake to overrule them today.  Instead, we recognize that they no longer apply in the same way when dealing with the granting of a monetary award [in a divorce action]”.  Id. at 93.

2.   IN DIVORCE CASES, THE COURT HAS BROAD DISCRETION IN                                AWARDING CONTRIBUTION OR CRAWFORD CREDITS BETWEEN                          DIVORCING SPOUSES

In contrast, the Court has broad equitable powers in determining the amount of contribution to be awarded when a divorcing spouse has paid more than half of the joint mortgage obligation during the parties’ separation.  In the divorce scenario, contribution is known as a “Crawford credit”.  See Crawford v. Crawford, 293 Md. 307 (1982).  

Maryland courts have uniformly held that it has broad discretion not to award contribution or Crawford credits or to award a credit of less than 50% to the spouse who has been paying the mortgage during separation to prevent an inequitable result.  See Cassamise v. Cassimese, 130 Md.App. 505, 525 (2000); Gordon v. Gordon, 174 Md.App. 583, 641 (2007) (holding the court is not obligated to award such contribution between the husband and wife at the time of divorce”).  The rationale was explained in Kline v. Kline, 85 Md.App.  28, 48 (1990): “The reason contribution is not mandatory at the time of divorce is that contribution is an equitable principle and the ability to grant a monetary award under the [Marital Property] Act enables the chancellor to achieve more complete equity than can be done through a Crawford contribution”.

In fact, requiring a Crawford contribution “could create the very inequity which the [Marital Property] Act was designed to prevent”.  Spessard v. Spessard, 64 Md.App. 83, 96 (1985).   Therefore, the “Court must exercise its discretion to determine whether Crawford credits are warranted” to achieve a “total disposition of [marital property] that is equitable”.   Woodson v. Saldana, 165 Md.App. 480, 493 (2005) and Spessard at 96.

              3.   MECHANISM OF AWARDING CONTRIBUTION

The contribution calculation can be accomplished by having the “entire amount of the advance be deducted from the net proceeds of the sale and repaid to the paying cotenant before dividing the balance between the cotenants”.  Id. at 55.  This method was used in Crawford v. Crawford, 293 Md. 307, 311 (1982).

The same mathematical result can be reached by dividing “the net proceeds of the sale between the paying cotenant and the non-paying cotenant and then deducting one-half of the advance from the share of the non-paying cotenant and augmenting the paying cotenant’s share by the amount of that deduction.  Kamin-A-Kalaw at 55.  This method was used in Pino v. Clay, 251 Md. 454, 458 (1968).

 

 

0 Comments

Submit a Comment

Complimentary Case Consultation

To contact us simply complete this form or contact us using the information provided below.

Receive Complimentary Case Consultation

Law Office of Stewart Andrew Sutton, LLC
8 Executive Park Court
Germantown, Maryland 20874
Telephone: 301-916-5000
Fax: 301-916-1201
E-Mail:
stewart.andrew.sutton@gmail.com