Maryland’s highest court affirms $10,000 cap on damages to household pets

by | Jun 8, 2021 | Firm News | 0 comments

Maryland Courts and Judicial Article section 11-110 states that an owner of a household pet may recover up to $10,000 in damages when his or her pet is injured or dies.  Damages include the fair market of the pet, if the pet dies, and the reasonable cost of veterinary care.

However, a pet owner cannot recover damages for mental and emotional distress or punitive damages from the death of a pet, even if someone intentionally killed the pet.  That was the holding of the recent case of Anne Arundel County v. Reeves, ___ Md. ___ (June 7, 2021). 

Maryland characterizes household pets as property.   This has created an anomalous situation.  If someone intentionally kills their neighbor’s dog, the family can recover no more than $10,000 for the loss of their dog.  But if the same person intentionally destroyed a painting of their neighbor’s dog, the family can recover both the fair market value of the painting as well as punitive damages.

Many other states recognize a greater right of recovery for injured or killed pets.  More than 50 years ago, the Florida Supreme Court held in LaPorte v. Associated Independents, Inc., that  when someone maliciously injures a pet, damages are not limited to the fair market value of the pet.

I advocate that Maryland should permit the recovery of emotional distress damages for  pet owners when their pet is injured or dies as a result of grossly negligent or intentional conduct.

 

 

 

0 Comments

Submit a Comment

Complimentary Case Consultation

To contact us simply complete this form or contact us using the information provided below.

Receive Complimentary Case Consultation

Law Office of Stewart Andrew Sutton, LLC
8 Executive Park Court
Germantown, Maryland 20874
Telephone: 301-916-5000
Fax: 301-916-1201
E-Mail:
stewart.andrew.sutton@gmail.com